NANFA-- Pike could devastate fisheries (article)

Jay DeLong (
Thu, 30 Jan 2003 10:43:27 -0800


Pike could devastate fisheries
Scientists say predator could devastate Delta

Tom Stienstra, Chronicle Outdoors Writer Wednesday, January 29, 2003

A predator fish that could endanger salmon and other fish populations
throughout Northern California has survived efforts to poison it and has
multiplied to alarming levels, according to the state Department of Fish
and Game.
State biologists captured and killed 17,635 northern pike last year at Lake
Davis near Portola (Plumas County), according to Fish and Game. That is up
from 6,358 in 2001 and 600 in 2000.
Scientists fear that if this invasive, nonnative fish escapes downstream
from Lake Davis, it could multiply further and take over the Sacramento-San
Joaquin River Delta in similar fashion, threatening fisheries and
endangered species.
"These new numbers are stunning to everybody who has monitored the
situation," said Fish and Game official Patrick Foy.
The department poisoned the lake in 1997, at a cost of $10 million in fines
and expenses, despite the opposition of local residents and some
environmentalists. But the pike survived -- or, as many locals believe,
were reintroduced.

Last summer, Foy called the pike a time bomb and said that "every day that
goes by with pike in the lake, the Delta (and its migratory fisheries) is
at risk."
The northern pike looks something like a set of crocodile jaws propelled by
a powerful tail fin. With its ability to reproduce and its appetite for
other fish, pike are dangerously well-equipped to take over ecosystems.
Despite efforts to kill as many pike as possible with netting, explosives,
electro-shock and other methods, at a cost of $500,000 per year, there are
more pike than ever at Lake Davis.
Earlier this month, Plumas County Supervisor B.J. Pearson even floated the
idea of draining the lake, a major recreation destination in the region.
Scientists believe that by itself wouldn't do the job and that the water
that would remain below the outlet, and in the feeder streams, would need
to be poisoned also.
"We believe it is not a simple solution," said Julie Cunningham, an
environmental scientist for the Department of Fish and Game. "Draining
would also require treatment (poison). There would be a standing pool of
water at the dam and an existing stream in the valley (that would have to
be poisoned). There is also the prospect of fish, larvae or eggs getting
out during the draining."

The results can be catastrophic when pike are mixed with trout, salmon and
other species. In particular, the endangered winter-run salmon and Delta
smelt could be wiped out if pike were able to populate the Sacramento-San
Joaquin River Delta. That would also negate $250 million spent in efforts
to restore the winter-run salmon.
Scientists have seen firsthand what can happen if pike escape into salmon
Michael Meinz of the American Fisheries Society described a similar
situation in Alaska, where pike that were introduced in a lake 20 years ago
escaped downstream into the Susinta River drainage. The pike now inhabit 90
lakes and 44 river systems in the region and have destroyed runs of silver
and sockeye salmon and 60 percent of the rainbow trout populations.
Lake Davis is about 50 miles northwest of Reno in southern Plumas County,
set at 5,775 feet in the Sierra Nevada. Unlike most mountain lakes, Davis
supports a rich aquatic biology, with an abundant food chain and weed
growth. Yet it freezes over in winter, simulating conditions on lakes in

To keep pike from spreading downstream from Davis into Grizzly Creek, the
state has installed a deep-water outlet where the water passes through
grates and a fish grinder.
"The scientists are confident that will keep them in Davis," Foy said.
"Anything bigger than four inches gets chopped up. Anything smaller is
unlikely to be at the depth of the discharge."

Yet Foy said the greatest fear is not juvenile pike slipping downstream
through the fish grinder. "Our greatest fear is a malicious person who
places them in some other lake," he said.
Many locals in Plumas County believe that northern pike were illegally
planted at Davis by a homesick local trying to replicate fishing conditions
in Minnesota or Wisconsin. In those states, pike co-exist with smallmouth
bass, walleye and muskie and provide a popular fishery.
"You can spend millions again to get rid of the pike," said Al Bruzza,
owner of the Sportsmen's Den in nearby Quincy, "and then the next year,
somebody shows up and dumps in some more pike.
"Then you've gone to extraordinary lengths and cost to get rid of the pike,
and you still have them anyway," Bruzza said.
But Foy said DNA evidence suggests a far more complex problem.
"What we've learned from DNA testing is that at least 50 pike had to be
introduced to Davis in order to have the genetic diversity we're seeing,"
Foy said.

Jay DeLong
Olympia, WA 
/"Unless stated otherwise, comments made on this list do not necessarily
/ reflect the beliefs or goals of the North American Native Fishes
/ Association"
/ This is the discussion list of the North American Native Fishes Association
/ To subscribe, unsubscribe, or get help, send the word
/ subscribe, unsubscribe, or help in the body (not subject) of an email to
/ For a digest version, send the command to
/ instead.
/ For more information about NANFA, visit our web page,