NANFA-- Escalating the War Against Predator Pike

Jay DeLong (
Mon, 11 Feb 2002 08:27:12 -0800

February 4, 2002
LA Times

Escalating the War Against Predator Pike
Environment: State wildlife agency plans to use detonator cord in Lake
Davis to kill the fierce fish that dines on prized trout. Critics say the
effort is doomed.


They have been poisoned, stunned and scooped into nets. Soon, they may be
blown up.

This spring, the state plans to launch a new line of attack on the
thus-far-indomitable northern pike of Lake Davis. The Department of Fish and
Game intends to explode detonation cord in pockets of the Plumas County
reservoir to kill the unwanted pike, which prey on the lake's trout.

The process will not, the department says, be like setting off land mines.
Rather, the small explosions will send pressure waves into the water,
bursting the air bladders of any nearby fish. They will die, but most will
stay relatively intact. The planned assault is the latest strategy in state
attempts to control the northern pike, a big, hungry fish that mysteriously
made its way into the lake in the early 1990s and refused to leave.

The state dumped chemical poison into Lake Davis in 1997, wiping out its
fish population. But some pike survived. They have since rapidly reproduced,
and last summer, more than 6,300 pike were taken from the lake by fish and
game personnel.

For now, the fish and game department seems to have given up hope of ridding
Lake Davis of the pike. The goal instead is to control their numbers so they
don't destroy the lake's prized trout fishery or spread downstream, where
they could wreak havoc on valuable salmon fisheries.

Detonation cords have been used before in California to kill fish
threatening salmon in the Eel River system on the North Coast, said fish and
game senior biologist Ivan Paulsen. They have never been used in Lake Davis,
which in the past has functioned as a drinking water source for local

A recently released environmental report, now under public review, concluded
that detonation would have no significant impact on the lake. Paulsen said
experiments conducted for the study indicated that the detonations would
leave some trace chemicals in the lake, but in quantities so minute they
would be undetectable.

The detonations would kill any nearby fish and amphibians, including the
lake's trout. Trout would be restocked, and some of the dead trout would be
left onshore as food for bald eagles that nest nearby.

Fran Roudebush, chairwoman of the Lake Davis Steering Committee, said that
once locals understand that the state is not going to blow up the lake, they
are not objecting to the plan. A public hearing on the matter will be held
Tuesday in Portola.

More controversial, she said, is talk about draining the lake to get rid of
the pike. Fish and game officials have placed that option at the bottom of
their list.

But Plumas County supervisors have expressed an interest in having the state
drain the reservoir and store the water downstream, so the county could sell
it and use the revenue to offset losses in tourism and sport fishing that
the region would suffer until the lake refills. That would include buying
any homes people wanted to sell when the lake was dry.

The supervisors have contacted the state about the proposal but have not
received a response, said county Supervisor B.J. Pearson.

Residents have no particular objection to the detonation plan, he added.
But, "at best, it's going to kill a few pike. It's not going to solve the

Biologist Paulsen said the detonations should kill pike quite efficiently. A
one-acre test detonation will be conducted in the reservoir in April. Water
quality will be sampled as well as the intensity of the shock waves.

If all goes well, the state would use detonation cord in areas of up to 10
acres where pike are concentrated. In 2003 and 2004, areas of up to 20 acres
would be treated.

Resembling clothesline, the cord would be run in lengths back and forth
through the water. Any fish within 21 feet of a detonation would be killed.

The article can be viewed at:

Visit at

/"Unless stated otherwise, comments made on this list do not necessarily
/ reflect the beliefs or goals of the North American Native Fishes
/ Association"
/ This is the discussion list of the North American Native Fishes Association
/ To subscribe, unsubscribe, or get help, send the word
/ subscribe, unsubscribe, or help in the body (not subject) of an email to
/ For a digest version, send the command to
/ instead.
/ For more information about NANFA, visit our web page,